Wednesday, November 23, 2022

Refighting the Battle of Beersheba 1917

Despite regular gaming I don't very often refight purely historical battles, however one of my gaming group was keen to try out a couple of tweaks to the Contemptable Little Army rules to refight the Battle of Beersheba which saw the British Expeditionary Force including the Australians and New Zealanders take on the Turkish Yidrim Army who were holding on to the town of Beersheba and their precious water wells.


The Turkish line filled with Turks and native Arabs - surely no one would be mad enough to assault these fixed defences.


The 4th Victoria and the 12th NSW Light Horse Regiments who were in fact mounted infantry used their 18inch bayonets as sabres in the charge.


You would have thought that charging across open ground against trenches would be suicide however the Turks had failed to place barbed wire across their trench line and the MG’s and Artillery was set to long range which overshot the charging line.


Charging across the open terrain the horsemen rushed towards the defenders, true to form the Turkish shooting was terrible and very few casualties were inflicted on the attackers.



Whilst some of the horsemen dismounted and fought through the trenches a significant number leapt the trenches and secured the wells.
The Turks initially held the first wave of horsemen, but the 2nd and 3rd broke the back of the defenders.

True to history the town was captured, and the Turks lost 5 times the number of Attackers...
What difference would a few rolls of barbwire made.

14 comments:

  1. Looks great...and bloody, poor cavalry!

    ReplyDelete
  2. LoveLy looking battle and a really interesting battle set up as you say you don’t often see cavalry against trenches !

    ReplyDelete
  3. Replies
    1. Thanks Jim, John does have a very nice collection, far too much horse for me...

      Delete
  4. It is funny how we in Australia commemorate the defeat at Gallipoli but ignore this great victory at Beersheba.
    It also shows how unorthodox tactics sometimes win the day - mounted infantry acting as cavalry.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Good fun to play, I figured I might stand chance in the trenches but they came on so very fast.

      Delete
  5. I think my wife's grandfather might have been involved in this, he (and his brother, I think) were in the New Zealand Mounted Rifles in the Middle East. Did you have to include scenario specific rules to ensure Turkish artillery and mg fire was pretty ineffective, or was it all just left to the dice gods?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes all the MG's and Artillery always fired at long range and it was split across 1-3 columns hence the cactus dividers in pic 4. The Infantry only had a range of 12" so really only got 1 or 2 rounds of fire in to the charging cavalry.

      Delete
  6. Fine game there Stu and nice to see a different theatre being gamed:).

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Another one of those butterfly projects..... :-)

      Delete
  7. But, but, but... they are mounted infantry! They aren't supposed to charge! Referee! Referee!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That's what I thought Captain.... cheating.....

      Delete